Myths and Facts About Protein Powders: Part 4
Protein Supplements: Quantity and Timing (Part 4)
In this part I will discuss mainly about Protein supplements their quantity and timing. Quantity matters according to age, gender and purpose. Males require high amount of protein in general. The older people and growing children need greater amount of protein for muscle preservation and growth respectively.
- Selection of protein according to the goals
- Contraindications while using protein supplements
- Quantity and Timing of Protein Supplements
Selection of Protein
Do you experience bloating, gas or loose stools after taking protein powders?
There are likely chances that you are suffering from lactose intolerance. Consider replacing the dairy proteins to plant based proteins to avoid any lactose. But if, still want to have dairy proteins, try to switch to Whey containing low lactose such as whey isolate. The colours, preservatives & flavours can lead to these symptoms as well. Read label while selecting protein.
Using Protein Supplement for Fat loss
If you want to use protein for the purpose of losing fat or weight, then keep in mind proteins to a poor diet can do more harm than good. The processing makes protein absorption easy and faster. This translates into high insulin response. Poor diet with protein supplement impedes fat loss by raising sugar levels. There are few studies which supports that whey protein boosts fat loss, and that’s true only, when used with right diet and exercise program.
For Muscle Mass and Strength
If the goal is to increase muscle mass and strength, then Whey based proteins take lead. Few studies proves that Whey supplementation with resistance training program leads to increases in muscle mass and strength. [Study]
Contraindications
- People suffering from high uric acid or gout should avoid protein powders. Purine containing foods contain nitrogen and uric acid is the by-product of purine metabolism. So people should exercise the control over total protein intake from protein supplements
- Protein supplements may raise creatinine levels and affect kidney functions in people with existing renal dysfunction. This doesn’t mean that people will get kidney problems or high creatinine with protein consumption.
- Lactose intolerant people should avoid Whey concentrate and casein based proteins (read the label for lactose content)
- People with digestive disorders should avoid dairy-based protein powders.
- Dairy protein can aggravate acne or skin disorders
- Protein powders are highly insulinogenic and use it with caution in diabetics. Adding fibre or oil to the protein shake such as coconut oil lowers insulin response
- Whey protein interfere with the absorption of medications including Antibiotics
- Whey interferes with action of Levodopa, an anti-psychotic drugLow quality proteins has lot of fillers to make the bulk of protein powder. This includes higher than average calcium content. Taking extra calcium in form of protein powder plus diet can increase the risk of kidney stones.
- High protein in the diet decreases the Sex Hormone Binding Globulin (SHBG). It is a protein which bounds most hormones including estrogen and testosterone. High protein diet lowers SHBG rendering higher levels of free testosterone and estrogens. This works positively for men by raising free testosterone while negatively for women by raising free estrogens. Higher than the normal estrogens in female lead to a condition known as estrogen dominance. Many cancers, endometriosis, infertility and fibroids has positive links to higher circulating free estrogens. So if you are planning to use protein supplement don’t overdo it.
Quantity and Timing of Protein Supplements
Quantity and timing also depends upon the purpose and goal for taking protein supplement
- Most proteins are best suited for consumption after a resistance training session or any physical activity including muscular efforts. The proteins like casein can be at bedtime for sustained release of amino acids to aid muscle repair. Whey isolates or hydrolysates are best kept for Intra-workout or post-workout use. The same rule applies to vegan proteins. Vegan proteins are mostly the isolate form, rice and pea having minimum fibre. The hemp protein has the highest fibre content and low insulinogenic response. Therefore, you can use it any smoothie or as a stand-alone product.
- People desiring to consume protein supplement for fat loss should avoid them during the day except post workout because of their higher insulinogenic response. High insulin levels during normal course of day shut down fat burning process while the same effect during post-workout boost muscle repairing and rebuilding.
Conclusion
1. Timing
Use Protein powders judiciously and to the minimum. One should first focus of diet, try to get as much protein as possible from natural sources whether veg or non-veg foods. Strength athletes & bodybuilders have higher protein demands than the normal average person. Extremely High-protein diets for long periods poses various health issues.
The high protein diet makes your pH more acidic and most diseases or ill health arises when our pH balance shifts from an alkaline to acidic. It’s best to add double the portion of alkaline foods in your high protein diet.
All vegetables, salads, citruses are alkaline foods. Don’t use protein powders for Fat Loss. It is better to work with a Qualified Practitioner rather than wasting money on finding a quick fix solution for Fat loss though Protein powders.
2. Quantity
- Protein Powder intake should not exceed over 20-25% of total protein intake for an individual. Body building websites, magazines and body builders tell you to take 2-4 scoops per day because they are endorsing the products. The companies want you to consume more and finish it as soon as possible. So you will buy it again which means more sale. Bodybuilders consume higher doses of protein powders and still won’t gain any fat or face any hindrances during fat loss. The reason behind this that they are usually below 10% body fat and quite insulin sensitive. They are on anabolic steroids most of the times. They can handle high than normal surges of sugar levels and insulin but normal people don’t.
- Vegan or Vegetarians should consume some kind of protein powder to meet their minimum daily protein requirement. For, a normal human being, the protein requirement is usually 0.7-0.8 gm per kg of bodyweight. You can cover this amount by eating more protein enriched foods such as legumes, lentils, beans, nuts and seeds. Plus, adding 10-15 gm of high quality protein powder from the above sources do no harm.
- Proteins also plays an important role in detoxification process. The people with low protein intake have toxic burden because of the unavailability of amino acids during conjugation phase. The amino acids form intermediate compounds with toxins for their effective removal from the body. Glutamine, glycine plays an active role in Glutathione production. Glutathione supports detoxification pathways. Read about Detoxification and how protein supports detoxification here.
NOTE: Protein Powders are not Fat Burners. Use them under judiciously and under professional guidance.